Periodic updates / Series
15
October
2026

EU-mandated migration-related fundamental rights monitoring and investigations - 2026 Update

EU law requires independent monitoring of certain migration-related activities such as screening, the asylum border procedure and forced returns. This publication provides an overview and an update on the functioning of this EU-mandated monitoring. The report also provides an update on investigations into reported incidents of ill-treatment at borders and shows that there are still significant gaps when it comes to investigating promptly and effectively rights violations at borders.

Article 47 of the Charter of Fundamental Rights of the EU provides that everyone whose rights and freedoms guaranteed by EU law are violated has the right to an effective remedy before a tribunal. The way Member States organise their justice systems, including how to conduct official investigations into rights violations, is primarily a matter of national law. Case law by the ECtHR requires investigations into alleged violations of the ECHR to be prompt and effective.

Article 10 (1) of the Screening Regulation expressly obliges Member States to adopt relevant provisions to investigate allegations of non-respect for fundamental rights in relation to the screening. Member States must ensure, where appropriate, referral for the initiation of civil or criminal justice proceedings in accordance with national law. This applies in cases of failure to respect or to enforce fundamental rights.

Substantiated allegations of failure to respect fundamental rights must be dealt with effectively and without undue delay (Article 10 (2) of the Screening Regulation). Independent national fundamental rights monitoring mechanisms must be allowed to trigger investigations and to monitor the progress of such investigations.

Human rights actors have been regularly reporting serious, recurrent and widespread rights violations against migrants and refugees at the EU’s borders. In its migration and fundamental rights bulletin 1/2026 and bulletin 2/2026, FRA reiterated that gaps regarding promptness and effectiveness of investigations lead to a perception of impunity. This risks undermining the rule of law, one of the fundamental values on which the Union is founded under Article 2 TEU.

In 2024, FRA issued guidance on investigating alleged ill-treatment at borders. A 2025 FRA update on investigations into alleged ill-treatment at the EU’s external borders found no structural changes improving the effectiveness of national investigations.

The following section contains FRA’s annual analysis of investigations into reported rights violations at borders for 2020-2025. It covers national judicial (criminal) and disciplinary investigations. It also describes the accountability mechanisms by the fundamental rights offices in Frontex and the EUAA and ends with developments at the ECtHR.


2.1. Judicial investigations

As in previous years, FRA asked 16 EU Member States, with an external land or sea border that experiences irregular crossings, for information regarding criminal investigations into rights violations at borders. Disaggregated data on such investigations are not available in most Member States. FRA, therefore, complemented the information received from the national authorities with information collected through lawyers engaged in relevant court cases.

Table 2 lists pending and closed judicial investigations in the period from 1 January 2020 to 31 December 2025. Due to data gaps, the table is not comprehensive.

Table 2 – Judicial investigations opened in 16 EU Member States from 2020 to 2025

Member State

Reply by authority

Other sources

Number of cases

Number of convictions

Alleged conduct (selected)

Bulgaria

No

Civil society

5

0

Excessive use of force and theft during apprehension and/or summary removal to Türkiye; obstruction to search and rescue

Croatia

Yes

Ministry of Interior

24

0

Torture, inhuman or degrading treatment, rape, robbery, unlawful deprivation of liberty, abuse of position of authority

Cyprus

Yes (for 2023)

UNHCR and civil society

0

0

 

Estonia

Yes

 

0

0

 

Finland

Yes

 

0

0

 

France

No

Civil society

9

0

Manslaughter and non-assistance to people in danger (drowning in the Channel), ill-treatment and abandonment of people unable to protect themselves, theft

Greece

No

Parliamentary question of 3 March 2026

207

0

Ill-treatment, failure to assist, theft, abduction, breach of duty, abuse of power

Hungary

Yes

 

25

8

Assault, misconduct, physical abuse

Italy

No

legal actors

1

0

Negligent shipwreck, multiple negligent manslaughter

Latvia

Yes

Internal Security Office, State Border Guard

2

0

Unlawful confiscation of property; excessive use of force

Lithuania

Yes

 

3

0

Severe health impairment, abuse of authority; failure to perform duties

Malta

No

Civil society

1

0

Wilful homicide and attempted wilful homicide (delayed rescue)

Poland

No

News item by public prosecutor

38

0

Abuse of power and failure to fulfil duties

Romania

Yes

Border Police

3

0

Abusive behaviour, aggression, and theft

Slovakia

Yes (for 2023)

 

0

0

 

Spain

No

Ministry of the Interior, civil society, and open sources

4

1

Homicide by gross negligence, denial of assistance, beating causing loss of vision, excessive use of force

Total

 

 

322

9

 

Notes:

Yes = FRA received information from prosecutorial, judicial or other national authorities. 

No = FRA did not receive information from national authorities.

Source: FRA (2026)

Between 2020 and 2025, judicial authorities in 12 EU Member States opened at least preliminary investigations in 322 criminal procedures. Last year, in the period 2020-2024, FRA had documented 135 investigations.

The increase is due to more information being available on past proceedings in Greece. It does not reflect a trend towards more investigations.

On 11 March 2026, the Greek Legal Council of State responded to question No. 3575-273/03.03.2026 by the Hellenic Parliament providing a comprehensive list of judicial investigations in the past six years. Their reply, together with additional materials from the public prosecutors, is annexed to a civil society report issued on 11 July 2026.

Most investigations are discontinued at the preliminary investigations stage, often due to lack of evidence. As early as in the 2024 report on investigations, FRA acknowledged that there are objective challenges to investigating fundamental rights violations at borders. One of the barriers is that evidence regarding occurrences at night in remote locations is often scarce. To promote effective national investigations, FRA’s 2024 report contains guidance on overcoming evidentiary obstacles.

Two years later, there remain systemic gaps hindering the effective investigation of rights abuses. In Greece, the National Commission for Human Rights documented repeated allegations of rights violations at borders through its recording mechanism. In July 2026, in its submission to the Council of Europe Committee of Ministers, it described a recurring pattern, whereby cases are pending for prolonged periods of time. They are then dismissed as unfounded or are archived as the perpetrators remain unidentified. It noted that no case has ever resulted in the identification of perpetrators.

In some instances, an overly formalistic approach also hinders access to justice. For example, after the ECtHR found that Greece had violated the ECHR in A.R.E. v. Greece (7 January 2025), the Prosecutor's Office of the Thrace Court of Appeal refused to reopen national investigations. The ECtHR’s judgement did not introduce any new facts but simply assessed the already submitted evidence differently. Under Greek law, this does not justify the reopening of the case, as indicated in Greece’s action plan to implement the judgement.

Table 2 shows that only nine out of 322 cases led to a conviction, eight in Hungary and one in Spain. These are five convictions more, compared with FRA’s 2025 report.

All new convictions recorded by FRA in 2025 are from Hungary and concern mistreatment committed at or near the border. Sentenced persons include police officers, an armed security guard employed by the police as well as ‘border hunters’ (határvadászok), a special force associated with the police to counter irregular migration. The judicial authorities imposed suspended prison sentences in three cases, fines and, in one case, community service work.

In Poland, in March 2026, the Siedlce District Prosecutor's Office dissolved the special team of prosecutors. The team had been established by the Lublin Regional Prosecutor through Order No. 33/2024 of 17 April 2024 to conduct investigations into alleged rights violations reported between September 2021 and March 2024 near the Polish-Belarusian border. Some 34 cases were discontinued due to lack of conclusive evidence. Criminal charges have been pressed in four cases against border guard officers before local courts, the Public Prosecutor’s Office informed the public. These criminal proceedings were still pending at the end of August 2026.

Lawyers involved in the cases informed FRA that, as of July 2026, investigations into two major 2023 shipwreck incidents at the Mediterranean were ongoing: Cutro in Italy and Pylos in Greece. For Pylos, in May 2025 preliminary investigations concluded with referrals to main proceedings against 17 Hellenic Coast Guard officials, Refugee Support Aegean reported. In February 2025, the Greek Ombudsman, through its own investigations, identified a series of omissions by senior Hellenic coast guard officers in carrying out their search and rescue duties.

Judicial investigations concern a variety of national criminal law provisions ranging from abuse of power, allegations of excessive use of force to theft and homicide. A 2026 case from France, which is not included in the table as falling outside the reporting period, shows that investigations may also concern allegations of racist behaviour.

The Dunkerque public prosecutor opened an investigation involving civilian sailors aboard the Ridens, a vessel chartered by the French authorities for migrant rescue operations in the English Channel. This investigation – ongoing as of September 2026 – concerns charges of public insult on grounds of origin, ethnicity, nationality, race or religion, as well as endangering the lives of others.

Malta’s legal system allows victims to bring violations of fundamental rights protected by the Maltese Constitution and the ECHR before a court. One such case concerns the death of the 3-year-old Syrian girl after delayed rescue in 2022. It is pending before the Civil Court, First Hall (Constitutional Jurisdiction). As it is not a criminal case, case No. 344/2024 – Falzon Neil l-avukat noe et vs. il-Ministeru Ghal-Intern, Is Sigurtà u x-Xoghol et, is not included in Table 2.


2.2. Disciplinary investigations

In addition to criminal investigations, Member States have procedures for disciplinary investigations, which vary in objective and scope. They aim to sanction officers’ inappropriate conduct and to protect the reputation of law enforcement authorities.

Table 3 provides an overview of national disciplinary investigations conducted between 1 January 2020 and 31 December 2025 in 16 EU Member States. It is based on replies by competent national authorities to an annual FRA request. Three Member States – Bulgaria, Malta and Italy – never replied to FRA’s request. FRA did not receive any new information from Poland and Spain. For Member States that did not reply, FRA included cases reported by other sources, as indicated in the note to the table. Some incidents subject to disciplinary investigations listed in the table also subsequently resulted in judicial investigations.

Table 3 – Disciplinary investigations opened in 16 EU Member States from 2020 to 2025

Member State

Reply to FRA request

Number of reported cases

Number of cases in which sanctions were imposed

Alleged conduct (selected)

Bulgaria

No

1

n/a

Violent pushback

Croatia

Yes

25

7

Abuse of power; failure to perform official duties; theft; bodily harm

Cyprus

Yes

1

0

Common assault linked to violence upon boat arrival

Estonia

Yes

0

0

 

Finland

Yes

1

0

Pressure and threats in order to provide information

France

No

11

0

Deliberate violence; exposure to risk of death or injury; insulting language

Greece

Yes

103

0

Ill-treatment, torture, rape and theft during apprehension and/or summary removal to Türkiye; homicide; illegal use of firearms

Hungary

Yes

20

6

Abuse of power; use of dogs against migrants

Italy

No

n/a

n/a

 

Latvia

Yes

4

0

abuse of power; excessive use of force; unlawful confiscation of property

Lithuania

Yes

6

0

Excessive use of force; discrimination; abuse of power

Malta

No

n/a

n/a

 

Poland

Yes
(for 2024)

13

0

Harassment; misappropriation of personal belongings; causing damage to the health of migrants; unintentional manslaughter

Romania

Yes

5

0

Abusive behaviour; physical aggression; theft

Slovakia

Yes

0

0

 

Spain

Yes
(for 2023)

2

0

Physical injuries; assault

Total

 

192

13

 

Notes:

n/a = information not available.

Yes = FRA received information from national authorities.

No = FRA did not receive information from national authorities. For Bulgaria and France, the cases were reported for FRA’s 2024 report by FRA’s multidisciplinary research network FRANET after consultations with national human rights bodies, organisations providing support to refugees and migrants, and lawyers.

Source: FRA (2026), based on information from law enforcement bodies and/or ministries in charge of disciplinary investigations

From 2020 to 2025, FRA counted 192 disciplinary investigations across 12 EU Member States. This corresponds to 30 additional investigations compared to FRA’s last data collection covering the period 2020-2024. Most investigations occurred in Greece, Croatia, Hungary and Poland. In 2025, most disciplinary investigations were opened in Greece (22 investigations) and in Croatia (five investigations). National authorities also reported new investigations in Latvia and Lithuania.

None of the investigations concluded in 2025 led to disciplinary sanctions. As a result, the situation remains unchanged compared to FRA’s last update published in 2025. At the time, FRA reported that 13 disciplinary investigations resulted in sanctions: seven in Croatia and six in Hungary.

Sanctions included demotions, termination of service (sometimes conditional or suspended), fines, a delay in promotion and reprimands. The breaches of conduct concerned, among other things, abuse of power, police brutality, unlawful confiscation of property, and assault.


2.3. Accountability mechanisms by Frontex and EUAA fundamental rights officers

Under Article 111 of Regulation (EU) 2019/1896 on the European Border and Coast Guard, a person whose fundamental rights are directly affected by the conduct of staff involved in Frontex operational activities may submit a written complaint to Frontex.

According to data from the fundamental rights office’s 2025 Annual Report (section 3.2), over the last ten years, Frontex registered 427 complaints, 114 of them in 2025. Most complaints are, however, inadmissible – and thus remain unaddressed – typically because the alleged breach of fundamental rights did not occur as part of Frontex operational activities. Some of these complaints, nevertheless, raise serious fundamental rights issues. Examples include allegations of ill-treatment, inadequate conditions in reception facilities and unprofessional conduct of border guards.

The EUAA is also mandated to set up a complaint mechanism to ensure that fundamental rights are respected across its activities (Regulation (EU) 2021/2303, Article 51). A complaints mechanism was established in 2024 which allows anybody who considers that their rights have been violated by EUAA-deployed staff to submit a complaint.

The EUAA fundamental rights officer received 22 complaints in 2025, only one of which was admissible. The complaint related to alleged breaches of the principle of non-refoulement in Greece. Most were inadmissible, as they did not concern EUAA conduct, as described in the EUAA fundamental rights officer’s Annual Report 2025.

Every participant in Frontex operational activities needs to report any situation in which fundamental rights may have been violates by filing a ‘serious incident report’. This requirement is based on the reporting requirement in Article 38 (3) (h) of Regulation (EU) 2019/1896. Fundamental rights violations are one of the categories of serious incidents.

In 2025, the Frontex fundamental rights office launched 47 serious incident reports, out of which 12 concerned Greece, according to its 2025 Annual Report (section 3.1). The most common allegations concerned inhuman or degrading treatment, violations of the right to life, lack of access to asylum and collective expulsion. In 2025, the fundamental rights office closed 42 serious incidents. In seven of these cases, it found that at least one fundamental rights violation had occurred, while for 21 other cases violations were found likely to have occurred.

In case of violations or likely violations of fundamental rights which concern the conduct of national authorities, the Frontex fundamental rights office requests that the responsible national authorities initiate an independent inquiry. The fundamental rights officer noted that only six of the 53 incidents that he had sent so far to national authorities were investigated by independent national institutions or courts. No national investigation ever resulted in sanctioning responsible officers.

The examination of complaints and serious incidents reflects a commitment for access to justice at the EU level. For Frontex, most alleged rights violations concern the conduct by national officers operating within Frontex operations. There is a need to ensure better follow up to the fundamental rights officers’ findings, through national-level investigations. This would not only improve access to justice for victims but also strengthen the credibility of Frontex investigations.

Regarding the EUAA, the EU Ombudswoman reviewed a complaint concerning the EUAA (Case 229/2024/AML). She concluded in July 2026 that the agency had failed to ensure that caseworkers deployed in its asylum support teams in 2024 were prepared to properly conduct interviews with vulnerable asylum seekers. She recommended enhanced training for case workers, certain operational measures and an internal procedure to report mistakes in the conduct of asylum interviews and follow up on them.

The EUAA has been working on an escalation mechanism to report violations by the host Member State, to feed into the procedure in Article 18 (6) of the EUAA Regulation. To be effective, FRA considers that such mechanism should envisage a substantial role of the EUAA fundamental rights officer at each key step.


2.4. Cases before the European Court of Human Rights

In May 2026, the Council of Europe’s Committee of Ministers adopted the Chișinău Declaration, reaffirming their commitment to the ECHR and their support for the independence of the ECtHR. The declaration, which addresses challenges linked to migration, underlines the importance of the ECHR system in protecting and promoting human rights and the rule of law in Europe. It stresses that states hold primary responsibility for implementing the ECHR and that the ECtHR ultimately acts as a safeguard in case people’s rights and freedoms are not secured at the national level.

By 1 September 2026, the ECtHR had communicated at least 32 pending cases entailing alleged ill-treatment at the EU’s external borders to eight different Member States, most in the context of summary returns from Poland and Greece.


ECtHR cases alleging ill-treatment at the EU’s external borders pending in September 2026, by Member State

The following list outlines the number of communicated ECtHR cases alleging ill-treatment at the EU’s external borders by 1 September 2026.

Bulgaria (1):

Croatia (1):

Greece (8):

Hungary (2):

Latvia (3):

Lithuania (2):

Poland (12):

Source: FRA (2026) based on hudoc.echr.coe.int. The table does not include cases alleging only violations of Articles 2 or 3 of the ECHR upon return to a third country.

The ECtHR has issued several judgments in which it found that national investigations into migrants’ rights violations at borders were ineffective. They concerned allegations of violations of the right to life (Article 2 of the ECHR), including in the context of search and rescue at sea as well as allegations of torture or inhuman or degrading treatment (Article 3 of the ECHR) during apprehension and subsequent summary return. Table 4 illustrates selected shortcomings in national investigations the ECtHR identified.

Table 4 – Selected shortcomings in national investigations identified by the ECtHR 

Case reference and date of judgment

Selected gaps in national investigation

M. H. and Others v. Croatia (18.11.2021), Nos. 15670/18 and 43115/18

insufficient analysis of discrepancy between police officers’ statements; no inspection of mobile phones and police global positioning system; lawyer not informed;

Safi and Others v. Greece (7.7.2022), No. 5418/15

problems with interpretation leading to errors; applicants not given access to evidence;

Douaa Alkhatib and Others v. Greece, (16.1.2024), No. 3566/16

evidence not preserved;

A.R.E. v. Greece (7.01.2025), No. 15783/21

applicant’s brother not allowed to give evidence; authenticity of audiovisual materials not adequately assessed; no serious examination of materials (documents and witness statement) in the case file; disregard of documented systematic “pushbacks” practice from Greece to Türkiye;

F.M. v. Greece (14.10.2025), No. 17622/21

independence of investigating body; not allowing an independent expert to prepare a report on the shipwreck; no consideration of applicant’s vocal message;

Alhowais v. Hungary (2.2.2023), No. 59435/17

not all witnesses questioned; insufficient effort to locate witnesses outside Hungary; not all options explored to clarify factual contradictions; reliance on seriously deficient autopsy reports;

Shahzad v. Hungary (No.2) (5.10.2023), No. 37967/18

no active investigation of the ill-treatment;

Y.F.C. and Others v. the Netherlands (21.4.2026), No. 21325/19

no independent investigation; no effective victim participation in the investigation

Source: FRA (2026), based on hudoc.echr.coe.int.

This list of selected shortcomings serves as a reminder to judicial authorities in EU Member States to enhance the effectiveness of national investigations into alleged rights abuses at borders, ultimately combatting impunity and enhancing access to justice for victims.