Access FRA Opinion concerning an EU common list of safe countries of origin >>
“An EU safe countries of origin list can assist the EU confront the migrant crisis, as long as it is compliant with fundamental rights. It is essential that any migrant facing involuntary return has the opportunity, on the basis of his/her personal circumstances, to challenge any assumption of safety,” said FRA Director, Michael O’Flaherty. “From a fundamental rights point of view, the existence of a list of safe countries of origin is legitimate, however, it must be constructed and applied respecting fundamental rights. Above all, it must be administered in a manner that non-negotiably honours the right to asylum.”
Safe countries of origin are the asylum seekers’ countries of nationality where there is no risk of persecution. Member States compile lists of these countries to help fast track asylum applications. However, they differ widely in which countries are included in national lists. Their approaches to handling asylum applications from these countries also varies. This has partly led to a European Commission proposal to establish an EU common list of safe countries of origin which the European Parliament asked FRA to comment on.
FRA’s Opinion concerning an EU common list of safe countries of origin looks at the fundamental rights impact of the proposal. It finds that such a list should only be viewed in the wider context of overall EU asylum laws and responsibilities, and how they are being implemented in the Member States. However, it should not be the only tool to speed up asylum processing; more financial and human resources, as well as training, enhanced coordination between agencies etc. should be deployed to ensure individual assessments are still carried out.
If such a list was established it could fast track asylum applications which are unfounded. This could free up existing scarce resources to focus on dealing with bona fide claims, shorten processing times and make more space available at reception centres. However, the fundamental rights of all asylum seekers would need to be maintained and protected. These include:
FRA’s assessment serves to highlight potential areas of concern when establishing an EU common list of safe countries of origin. The opinions are meant to feed into the European Parliament’s own assessment of the Commission’s proposal.